0

Equivalent question: What Korean letters won't equal 1?

From: the homophonic group: a mathematical diversion → This is an exercise from Michael Artin's Algebra on, well, abstract algebra. In this exercise for the English language, words are equal if they are homophones, kind of like a formalisation of the joke that sin(x)/n=6. So in English:

  • bee=be → This implies e=1 by cancellation of b and e.

  • buy=by → This implies u=1 by cancellation of b and y.

  • rase=raze → This implies s=z by cancellation of r, a and e.

canvass=canvas → This implies s=1 by cancellation of c,a,n,v,a and s. By canvass=canvas and rase=raze, we have s=z=1.

Eventually, all 26 English letters will equal 1. Apparently, this was done for French and Czech.

2 Answers 2

1

It's an interesting application of abstract algebra in linguistics, but in the context of the answer to the other link it wouldn't be possible to create any relations A~B in the first place as there aren't Korean characters constructed with different consonants and vowels but sound the same. Even the two most similar sounding vowels ㅔ and ㅐ are strictly speaking pronounced differently.

0

This game can be applied to Korean. Examples:

  • = → This implies ㅅ=1 by cancellation of ㄱ, ㅏ and ㅂ.
  • = → This implies ㄹ=1 by cancellation of ㅅ, ㅏ and ㅁ.
  • 묶다=묵다 → This implies ㄱ=1 by cancellation of ㅁ, ㅜ, ㄱ, ㄷ and ㅏ.

I do not think this could be expanded to have all jamo equal 1, especially not the vowels.

1
  • This I think comes close to being the correct answer Commented Nov 18, 2022 at 12:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.